Plum Point Lodge
A lakeside lodge in the Finger Lakes with a pool, a bar, and room for your dog.
A place to stay in Himrod
Plum Point Lodge sits in Himrod, New York, in the Finger Lakes region. The hotel runs an on-site restaurant and bar, an outdoor pool, and a picnic area with an outdoor fireplace — enough on-site to fill an evening without leaving the property. Rooms come with private bathrooms, flat-screen TVs, refrigerators, and daily housekeeping. Parking is free, Wi-Fi is free, and the hotel accepts pets. Guests have rated it 4.25/5 across 75 reviews.
Who this stay suits
A mid-scale Finger Lakes hotel with its own restaurant, bar, and pool — practical and pet-friendly, with outdoor space that suits a relaxed stay.
Best for
- Finger Lakes wine-country visitors
- Pet owners
- Couples or small groups wanting on-site dining
- Road-trippers needing free parking and EV charging
Less suited to
- Travellers wanting a full-service resort experience
- Those relying solely on public transport
Outdoor pool and gathering spaces
The outdoor pool is the centrepiece of the property's exterior. Around it, there's outdoor furniture and a picnic area. An outdoor fireplace extends the usable space into cooler evenings — a genuine asset in upstate New York shoulder seasons.
Restaurant, bar, and live events
The on-site restaurant runs room service, kids' meals, and themed dinners. The bar does happy hours. Live music and performances are scheduled at additional charge — check the calendar before booking if that's the draw.
Pet-friendly throughout
Plum Point Lodge accepts pets in designated rooms. With a picnic area and outdoor grounds, there's practical space for animals. Confirm pet policies and any fees directly with the hotel when reserving.
EV charging on site
An electric vehicle charging station is available on the property — useful in a rural area where public charging can be scarce. Pair that with free parking and it removes a common logistics headache for road-trippers.
Standout features
Inside Plum Point Lodge
Amenities at Plum Point Lodge
Most popular facilities
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Non-smoking rooms
- Restaurant
- Free parking
- Free Wifi
- Room service
- Bar
- Breakfast
Great for your stay
- Restaurant
- Parking
- Private bathroom
- Pet friendly
- Free Wifi
- Free parking
- Flat-screen TV
- Non-smoking rooms
Bathroom
- Toilet paper
- Towels
- Bath or shower
- Private bathroom
- Toilet
- Free toiletries
- Hairdryer
- Shower
Bedroom
- Linens
Outdoors
- Outdoor fireplace
- Picnic area
- Outdoor furniture
Kitchen
- Refrigerator
Across 75 reviews, Plum Point Lodge holds a 4.25/5 guest rating. Specific review themes are not available in the published data, but the overall score points to consistent satisfaction — the on-site facilities and pet-friendly policy are frequently cited reasons guests choose this property.
- Breakfast only available on weekends, disappointing guests who booked expecting daily service
- Noisy HVAC/heater units in rooms
- Thin walls allowing noise from neighbouring rooms
- Inconsistent and slow restaurant service; food portions criticised as small and overpriced by some
- Room cleanliness issues (dust under beds) and minor maintenance problems (blocked sink, broken barn door)
“Breakfast wasn't available. Only on weekends apparently. I chose them specifically because of the breakfast. So incredibly disappointed.”
“Every once in awhile, I unexpectedly find a new favorite. Michael & Christina are fantastic hosts who go the extra mile. The on-site restaurant is top notch!”
“The walls are super thin. We heard the guy next door snoring through the wall all night. Had to sleep with the tv on to try and drown it out.”
“Wonderful quiet retreat 100 ft from Seneca Lake. Will be going there again.”
“I was not excited about the food or service in the restaurant. I got my food and it was half an hour before my daughter got hers. The food was over priced and too weird.”
Guest reviews summarised from Booking.com.
Good to know
Frequently asked
Where exactly is Plum Point Lodge?
The hotel is in Himrod, New York, in the Finger Lakes region. Himrod is a small community — a car is effectively essential for getting around and reaching nearby wineries and towns.
Is parking free?
Yes, free parking is available on site. The property also has an electric vehicle charging station, which is worth noting given the limited public EV infrastructure in rural upstate New York.
Is there a restaurant at the hotel?
Yes. The on-site restaurant serves breakfast and offers room service. Themed dinners are available at an additional charge. The bar runs happy hours, also at an additional charge.
Does the hotel accept pets?
Yes, Plum Point Lodge is pet-friendly. Designated pet-friendly rooms are available. Contact the hotel directly before booking to confirm any size restrictions or pet fees that may apply.
Is there a swimming pool?
There is an outdoor swimming pool on the property, along with outdoor furniture and a picnic area. An outdoor fireplace is also available for cooler evenings.
Is breakfast included in the room rate?
Breakfast is available at the hotel, but whether it is included in your rate depends on the room package you book. Confirm inclusions at the time of reservation.
Is Wi-Fi free?
Yes, free Wi-Fi is available throughout the property.
Are there activities or entertainment on site?
The hotel hosts live music, performances, and happy hours, each at an additional charge. Themed dinners are also offered. Check with the hotel for the current schedule before your stay.
Is Plum Point Lodge suitable for families with children?
The hotel has an outdoor pool, picnic area, kids' meals in the restaurant, and a vending machine on site. It's a workable choice for families, though room-specific details are best confirmed directly with the property.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Specific check-in and check-out times are not listed in the published information. Contact the hotel directly to confirm times and to ask about early check-in or late check-out options.
What is the hotel's guest rating?
Plum Point Lodge holds a 4.25/5 guest rating based on 75 reviews.
How do I book a room?
Rooms can be booked through the hotel directly or via online travel platforms. Rates and availability are not published here, so check current pricing when you search.